The Battle for Truth: Journalism in the Age of Trump
January 22, 2025 | Jeffrey Goldberg with Madeleine Brand: Inauguration Week: Where Are We Headed?
In a recent America at a Crossroads discussion, Jeffrey Goldberg, Editor-in-Chief of The Atlantic, shared his insights on the evolving role of journalism in an era of political chaos. Goldberg, a seasoned journalist with extensive experience covering domestic and international affairs, has witnessed firsthand the challenges of reporting on Donald Trump’s presidency. From Trump’s direct attacks on the press to his ability to manipulate the news cycle, Goldberg’s discussion shed light on the crucial role of accountability journalism in preserving democratic values.
The Challenges of Covering Trump’s Presidency
Trump’s return to power has once again placed him at the center of national consciousness, and with it comes his uncanny ability to dominate media coverage. As Goldberg noted, “No one is smarter in our so-called attention economy at getting our attention than Donald Trump.” His rapid issuance of executive orders, high-profile pardons, and provocative statements ensure that journalists remain in a constant state of reaction. By the time the media dissects one major policy move, another controversy takes center stage, creating a perpetual cycle that makes in-depth reporting difficult.
Moreover, Trump’s attacks on the press—calling journalists “horrible radical left lunatics” and “sleazeballs”—are not just rhetorical jabs; they shape public perception of the media. While these insults might seem dismissive, Goldberg pointed out an ironic effect: The Atlantic’s subscriptions often surge whenever Trump publicly criticizes it. However, this hostile environment has also contributed to the decline of trust in mainstream media, making the job of journalists even more challenging.
The Atlantic’s Approach to Journalism
Goldberg emphasized that The Atlantic is committed to “accountability journalism,” a principle that prioritizes in-depth reporting and analysis over partisan resistance. Unlike some outlets that position themselves explicitly against Trump, Goldberg insists that his magazine’s role is to report fairly and critically, whether a policy decision is made by a Republican or a Democrat. “If Trump does something serious—something that genuinely benefits the country—then we will say it,” he explained. However, he made it clear that facts remain non-negotiable, and The Atlantic refuses to publish articles that distort reality.
One of the key challenges in maintaining journalistic integrity, Goldberg explained, is the struggle with publishing pro-Trump perspectives that adhere to rigorous fact-checking standards. “The difficulty,” he said, “is that too many Trump supporters are living in an alternate reality.” Falsehoods about election fraud, the January 6th insurrection, and Trump’s business dealings often fail the basic test of journalistic accuracy.
The Erosion of Independent Journalism
A growing concern among journalists is the shifting media landscape, particularly the influence of billionaire owners on major news outlets. While The Atlantic benefits from the financial backing of Laurene Powell Jobs—who Goldberg praises for her unwavering commitment to editorial independence—other media organizations have not been so fortunate. The recent turmoil at The Los Angeles Times and The Washington Post highlights the dangers of media owners who prioritize business interests over journalistic integrity.
Goldberg acknowledged that Trump’s ability to punish media companies that challenge him poses a significant risk. Some owners, fearing retaliation, may soften their coverage or avoid controversial stories altogether. This chilling effect on the press underscores the need for steadfast journalistic institutions willing to prioritize truth over profit.
The Future of News in a Polarized Media Landscape
As social media continues to influence how people consume news, Goldberg warns that the traditional role of journalism is under threat. The rise of alternative media, misinformation, and viral conspiracy theories have eroded trust in credible reporting. “People don’t go to Joe Rogan to find out what neighborhood in L.A. is on fire,” he quipped. While entertainment-driven platforms may dominate engagement, real journalism remains essential for an informed citizenry.
The battle for truth in journalism is far from over. As Goldberg concluded, the mission remains clear: “Journalists must continue to investigate, fact-check, and present reality to the public—regardless of the political consequences.” In an age of disinformation, upholding these values is more important than ever.
About America at a Crossroads
Since April 2020, America at a Crossroads has produced weekly virtual programs on topics related to the preservation of our democracy, voting rights, freedom of the press, and a wide array of civil rights, including abortion rights, free speech, and free press. America at a Crossroads is a project of Jews United for Democracy & Justice.